Nov 18, 2026Leave a message

How to Choose a Linear Guide: Load, Stroke and Accuracy

Choosing a linear guide starts with the load path, not with a catalogue page. The three families - profile rail, round shaft and linear module - solve different problems, and picking the wrong family cannot be fixed by choosing a bigger size. This guide gives the selection sequence we use, including the deflection arithmetic that decides between round shaft and profile rail.

Start With the Load, Not the Catalogue

Before any part number, answer four questions about the axis:

  • Which directions does the load push? Down only, or also sideways and in twist?
  • Where is the centre of gravity relative to the bearings? An offset load becomes a moment, and moments are what separate the families.
  • What is the stroke? Long strokes change the structural problem from bearing capacity to rail or shaft deflection.
  • What is the accuracy budget? Positioning accuracy and running parallelism are set by the guide, and no amount of motor tuning recovers them.

Only after these four are answered does a size number mean anything.

Three Families and What Each Is For

Profile rail

A ground rail with a matching carriage that wraps it. Balls or rollers recirculate inside the block. Because the block wraps the rail, it resists load from all directions and resists moment loads directly. This is the family for machine tools, gantries, and any axis where the carriage plate is rigid and the load is offset from the bearing centre.

Round shaft

A hardened and ground round shaft with a bushing or a block running on it. Usually two shafts per axis, one above and one below, or two side by side. Cheap, widely available, tolerant of mounting error in the directions it does not constrain. Its weakness is that a round shaft bends - and on a long stroke, deflection rather than bearing capacity sets the limit.

Linear module

A complete actuator: aluminium extrusion, guide, drive (belt or ball screw) and carriage, supplied as one assembly. Fastest to integrate and hardest to get wrong, but less stiff than a purpose-built profile rail axis and harder to service when the belt or screw wears.

The Calculation That Decides Round Shaft Versus Profile Rail

A simply supported round shaft under a central load deflects by:

δ = F × L³ / (48 × E × I), with I = π × d⁴ / 64

For a steel shaft, E is about 206 GPa. The practical acceptance limit is usually L/1000 to L/2000 of the span for precision work, and up to L/500 for general handling.

The important property of this formula is the L³ term. Doubling the span increases deflection eight times. Doubling the shaft diameter reduces it sixteen times. That is why a long-stroke axis on round shaft suddenly needs an enormous diameter, and why profile rail wins at long strokes - the rail is supported continuously by the machine frame rather than spanning between two end supports.

If two shafts share the load, each carries roughly half, but only if the mounting is symmetric and the carriage is rigid. Asymmetric loading puts more on one shaft than the arithmetic suggests.

Load on Each Block, Not on the Carriage

On a four-block carriage, the payload divides unequally whenever the centre of gravity is off-centre. The worst-loaded block sets the life of the axis.

For a carriage with blocks at the corners of a rectangle of length a (along travel) and width b (across), a load W at an offset of x along travel and y across gives the maximum block load approximately as:

P_max ≈ (W/4) × (1 + 2x/a) × (1 + 2y/b)

This is an approximation for rigid plates, but it captures the mechanism: offsets multiply, and a load sitting at the edge of the carriage can put two to three times the nominal quarter-load on one block. Size for that block, not for the average.

Moment capacity is rated separately - Mx (roll), My (pitch), Mz (yaw) - and all three must be checked when the load is offset. Exceeding a moment rating does not show up as a smooth failure; it shows up as a block that runs rough and then brinells.

Stroke, Speed and Where the Limits Come From

Three different limits apply as stroke and speed rise, and they are often confused:

  • Deflection limit - the structural one described above. Sets maximum span for a given accuracy.
  • Critical speed - applies to the drive, not the guide. If the axis is ball-screw driven, the screw's critical speed and its whip at long strokes usually limit speed before the guide does.
  • Lubrication interval - applies to the guide. As speed rises, grease is consumed and flung faster, and the relubrication interval shortens.

For a belt-driven module, the belt's own speed rating and the pulley diameter set the limit. For a profile rail axis, the block's recirculation design sets a practical ceiling, and above that ceiling ball recirculation noise and heat become the constraint rather than load.

Environment Decides the Accessories

The guide itself is usually the least environment-sensitive part of the axis. The accessories decide whether it survives.

Environment What to add Why
Coolant spray, cast iron dust Scrapers plus bellows Chips enter the block and destroy the wiper lip first
Wood dust, abrasive powder Full bellows cover Wipers alone cannot keep out fine abrasive
Washdown, food contact Stainless rail option, food-grade grease Carbon steel rail corrodes under daily washdown
High ambient temperature High-temperature grease, check seal material Standard grease separates and drains out
Long unattended runs Centralised lubrication Manual greasing is the most common cause of premature failure

The single most common cause of a failed block in a real machine is not overload. It is a wiper that wore through and let chips into the raceway.

A Five-Step Selection Sequence

1. Define the load case. Forces in three axes, centre of gravity, duty cycle. 2. Choose the family using the deflection check for long strokes, and the moment check for offset loads. 3. Size the block from the static safety factor first, then confirm life with L = (C/P)³ × 50 km for ball type. 4. Pick preload and accuracy grade to match the accuracy budget, not higher than needed. 5. Specify the protection and lubrication for the actual environment, then confirm mounting-face flatness and shoulder height on the drawing.

Steps 1 and 5 are where projects go wrong. Steps 2 to 4 are arithmetic, and arithmetic is the easy part.

FAQ

How do I choose between HGR and SBR linear guides?

HGR is a profile rail - it resists load and moment in all directions and suits rigid carriage plates and machine tools. SBR is a supported round shaft - cheaper, easier to align, and adequate for lighter loads over shorter strokes. The deflection calculation above is the deciding test at long strokes; the HGR linear guide range and the SBR support rail range show both families side by side.

What stroke length makes profile rail the better choice?

There is no fixed number, because it depends on shaft diameter and accuracy budget. Run the L³ deflection check for the round shaft option. If the required diameter becomes impractical or the deflection exceeds L/1000, move to profile rail.

Do I need to calculate life if the axis is lightly loaded?

Yes, but it will not be the limiting factor. On lightly loaded axes the constraint is usually lubrication interval or contamination, not fatigue life. Check the static safety factor to rule out brinelling, then spend your effort on wipers and a lubrication schedule.

Can I mix guide families on one machine?

You can, and it is common - a profile rail on the cutting axis and round shaft on a transfer axis. Keep them on separate axes rather than mixing families within one axis, because the stiffness mismatch will load the stiffer guide preferentially. The linear guide category lists the families we supply with their size and preload options.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry